Moves · Enlightenment Toolkit
Enlightenment Toolkit
The Enlightenment was a set of techniques, not conclusions. Eleven named moves target common failure modes; they stack. Named patterns live in Essential Concepts; the public arena is Battle of Ideas.
Run the Stack
Default protocol for contested questions — seven steps, half an hour, private by default.
Practice surfaces
Full guide
Read the complete Enlightenment Toolkit essay — paste into any LLM or download the markdown.
Steelman builder
Build the strongest charitable form of a view before critique.
Assumption Archaeology
Surface hidden assumptions that would break the conclusion if false.
Quick Reference
Pocket cards for all eleven moves plus the Stack — offline-ready.
The eleven moves
- 1.Logical, not rhetoricalSet the mode: commit where the reasoning supports it; no balance for its own sake.
- 2.Socratic methodPointed questions one at a time — retrieval over generation.
- 3.SteelmanBuild the strongest charitable form of a view before critique.
- 4.Red-teamTry to break the position you find most convincing — including your own.
- 5.Assumption archaeologySurface hidden assumptions that would break the conclusion if false.
- 6.Definitional clarityPin down terms before arguing about fairness, nature, or extremity.
- 7.Verify the factsCheck titles, dates, authors — and whether the source supports the framing.
- 8.Symmetric applicationApply the same scrutiny to your preferred conclusion as to the opposite.
- 9.Strip-and-checkStrip loaded words; see if the recommendation still follows from structure.
- 10.Specificity demandForce a concrete instance, number, event, or testable prediction.
- 11.Pre-commitment falsifierName what would change your mind before locking the belief.
Vocabulary · arena
Moves without names are habits; names without practice stay abstract.
Concepts
SteelmanCharity as epistemology
Concepts
Assumption ArchaeologyHidden premises
Battle
Battle of IdeasSee these disciplines applied to live contested claims